When we talk about sustainability, our minds usually turn to water, energy, food, climate and natural resources. That is understandable: these are the foundations without which neither human beings…
When we talk about sustainability, our minds usually turn to water, energy, food, climate and natural resources. That is understandable: these are the foundations without which neither human beings nor civilization can carry on.
But the world we live in has changed. Water, energy, food, transport, trade, banking, ports, airports and government services are no longer separate systems. They now operate inside a tightly interconnected network of knowledge, communications, data, software and technology.
This raises a new question: is the sustainability of resources enough if we cannot guarantee the sustainability of the systems that manage them?
Repeated technical disruptions have shown that the failure of a widely used digital service is no longer a purely technical matter whose effects stop at computers or communication tools. In a highly interconnected world, a fault in one system can affect other sectors that depend on it, and can expose weaknesses that were invisible under normal conditions.
This does not mean technology has become more important than water or energy. There is no life without water, and no modern civilization without energy. But technology now plays a different role: it links many of civilization’s functions to one another. Think of the human body. Water, energy and food are the essentials of life, while technology, communications and data have become something like the nervous system, connecting the body’s organs and directing many of their functions. There is no point in asking whether blood or the nervous system matters more; both are essential. Yet a failure in the nervous system can stop healthy organs from doing their work.
We may need to take a step beyond sustainability toward a broader concept: civilizational resilience. Sustainability asks: how do we preserve resources and capabilities so they endure? Civilizational resilience asks: what happens when something actually goes wrong? Can a civilization absorb the shock, adapt to it, and come out stronger?
Here, returning to the thought of Ibn Khaldun is telling. The point is not to attribute modern terminology to him, but because his analysis of ‘umran (civilization) lets us see civilization as an interconnected system in which the state, society, the economy, knowledge and human relationships overlap.
Seen this way, the strength of a civilization does not rest on material resources alone. It also rests on society’s ability to organize those resources, produce knowledge, and build the institutions and relationships that make its continuity possible.
This reading lets us pose a very modern question: when does progress itself turn from a source of strength into a source of fragility?
Civilizations do not become fragile only at the moment a crisis strikes. Fragility may begin long before, when a system’s complexity, and the dependence of its parts on one another, outgrows its ability to cope with failure. This is one of the paradoxes of our age.
Modern development has been built on a constant drive for efficiency: more output, less consumption, greater speed, more interconnected systems and more automation.
But efficiency is not always synonymous with resilience. A system can be highly efficient under normal conditions yet extremely fragile if many functions depend on a single point, a single platform or a single provider, or if, in the name of efficiency, we give up the alternatives and capabilities we may need in a crisis.
So to the traditional question, “How efficient is the system?”, we should add another question that is just as important: what happens when this system fails?
This shift also changes how we understand infrastructure. Infrastructure in the twenty-first century is no longer just roads, ports, power stations and water networks. It also includes data and communications, knowledge and human capabilities, and institutions able to respond when the usual course of things breaks down.
Civilizational resilience can therefore be defined as a society’s ability to maintain its essential functions during crises, absorb shocks, adapt to them, and then recover its ability to function and to learn from what happened.
In my view, though, this definition should not stop at recovery. True resilience is not surviving a crisis only to return to the same point where we stood before it. It means learning from the crisis, identifying the weaknesses it revealed, fixing them, and becoming better prepared for whatever comes next.
Here we can borrow an idea deeply rooted in the UAE’s approach to crises: to emerge from a crisis stronger than we were when we entered it.
This, in my estimation, is civilizational resilience in its deepest sense. A resilient civilization is not one that never faces shocks; that is impossible. It is a civilization that can turn shock into knowledge, knowledge into reform, and reform into a greater capacity to face the next shock.
On this basis, it no longer makes sense to treat water, energy, food, technology and knowledge security as separate files. Energy needs technology and knowledge to be managed; technology needs energy; food needs water, energy and transport; and transport increasingly depends on communications and digital systems. Ultimately, all of these depend on people and institutions, and on their ability to make decisions and adapt to change.
So perhaps the right question is not which of these resources matters most. It is more useful to ask: how do we make the whole system able to keep going when one of its parts fails? And then: how do we make it learn from that failure so it emerges stronger?
Our vision of sustainability should therefore expand to include, alongside the sustainability of water, energy and food, the sustainability of technology, of knowledge, and of human and institutional capacity. The smartest city is not necessarily the most resilient, and the most automated institution is not necessarily the best able to withstand shocks. The amount of technology we use is not, on its own, enough to measure our progress unless we know what we will do when that technology stops working.
This is exactly where the difference between building for efficiency and building for continuity becomes clear. The first usually assumes the system will work as designed. The second assumes from the outset that failures, shocks and surprises are part of the future, and that a system’s strength shows not only in how it performs when it works, but in how it behaves when it fails.
In this way the philosophy of sustainability broadens. The goal is no longer only to preserve resources and avoid depleting them; it is also to sustain civilization’s ability to function, adapt and learn. In other words, we move from a sustainability that seeks to preserve what we have to a civilizational resilience that enables us to face whatever happens to us, and, wherever possible, to turn crises into opportunities to fix weaknesses and build a stronger system.
This, however, leads us to a harder question. Preparing for what we know might happen is possible, however difficult: we can study risks, estimate probabilities, build scenarios and set up alternatives. But how do we prepare for what we do not even know could happen? What if technology evolves faster than our ability to understand all of its future effects? And how can a civilization build resilience against risks that extend beyond what it knows, into what it does not know it does not know?
That is the question the next article will explore: civilizational resilience in the age of artificial intelligence, and how we prepare not only for the risks we can foresee, but also for a future that may surprise us with things we have not yet learned how to anticipate.
Back to news



