FREEDOM OF WORSHIP FOR JEHOVAH’S WITNESSES, PATIENT AUTONOMY, AND BIOLAW: JURISPRUDENTIAL CRITERIA IN CHILE, COLOMBIA, AND EUROPE
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.54878/y945na95Keywords:
Religious freedom, fundamental rights, freedom of worship, blood transfusions, human rights, diversity, integrationAbstract
This research aims to show how different courts have resolved the conflict between the right to life and the right to religious freedom of Jehovah's Witnesses when they have to undergo a blood transfusion prohibited by their religion. To do this, we will analyze the criteria used by the high courts of justice in Chile over the past 25 years. Likewise, we will study the criteria adopted on the matter by the Colombian Constitutional Court and what the European Court of Human Rights has recently stated, whose rulings reflect its consistency with recognizing the full exercise of the right to religious freedom and worship. As a preliminary step and for greater understanding, we consider it essential to briefly review the theological foundations of the prohibition against giving/receiving blood by Jehovah's Witnesses, which justify their decision.
References
ALEXY, Robert (1993): Teoría de los derechos fundamentales (Madrid, Centro de Estudios Constitucionales).
NÚÑEZ LEIVA, José Ignacio (2010): “Estatuto constitucional del embrión humano”, en Hemiciclo, Revista de Estudios Parlamentarios, N.º 2, pp. 67-86.
GREDILLA DÍAZ, Elena; DE VICENTE SÁNCHEZ, Jesús; PÉREZ FERRER, Antonio; GARCÍA FERNÁNDEZ, Javier; y REINOSO BARBERO, Francisco (2006): “Fundamentos del rechazo a la transfusión sanguínea por los Testigos de Jehová. Aspectos ético-legales y consideraciones anestésicas en su tratamiento”, en Revista Española de Anestesiología y Reanimación, vol. 53, N.º 1, pp. 31-41.
SALINAS ARANEDA, Carlos (2004): Lecciones de Derecho Eclesiástico del Estado de Chile (Valparaíso, Ediciones Universitarias de Valparaíso).
SALINAS ARANEDA, Carlos (2008): “El Estado no confesional y laicismo”, en Revista de Derecho de la Universidad Católica del Norte, año 15, N.º 1, pp. 183-202.
HOLY BIBLE (2005): Holy Bible (Spain, Editorial Verbo Divino).
“Bloodless Surgery.” Available at: www.redclinica.cl/plantilla/programas-y-centros/cirugia-sin-transfusion.aspx (visited on September 23, 2026).
ATALAYA MAGAZINE (2004): “Let’s Properly Value the Gift of Life.” Available at: www.jw.org/en/library/magazines/w20040615/lets-properly-value-the-gift-of-life/ (visited on September 23, 2026).
Cited legal provisions
Political Constitution of the Republic of Chile, Supreme Decree No. 1,150, of October 21, 1980.
Law No. 19,638, on the Legal Constitution of Churches and Religious Organizations, of October 14, 1999.
Law No. 20,584, regulating the rights and duties that people have in relation to actions linked to their health care, of April 24, 2012.
Cited case law
a) Chile
Court of Appeals of Valparaíso, Protection Action, “Araya with Vergara,” of October 24, 2008, Roll No. 554-2008.
Court of Appeals of Talca, Protection Action, “Chacón Fernández vs. Ramírez Muñoz and another,” October 30, 2010, Case No. 935-2010.
Court of Appeals of La Serena, Protection Action, “Campos Castillo vs. La Serena Regional Hospital,” February 13, 2015, Case No. 126-2015.
Court of Appeals of Valparaíso, Protection Action, “Naval Hospital Almirante Nef vs. Rojas,” March 25, 2015, Case No. 977-2015.
Supreme Court, Appeal, “Rojas Aguilera vs. Naval Hospital Dr. Almirante Nef,” April 20, 2015, Case No. 5,027-2015.
Court of Appeals of Rancagua, Protection Action, “García Diéguez vs. Contreras Encina,” December 24, 2016, Case No. 4,841-2016.
Supreme Court, Appeal, “Director of Rancagua Regional Hospital vs. Contreras Encina,” March 16, 2017, Case No. 1,764-2017.
Rancagua Court of Appeals, Protection Action, “Director of the Libertador Bernardo O’Higgins Regional Hospital,” May 23, 2018, Case No. 1,278-2018.
Talca Court of Appeals, Protection Action, “Poblete Adasme vs. Dambolena Dimperio,” July 27, 2018, Case No. 2,026-2018.
Supreme Court, Appeal, “Rancagua Regional Hospital vs. Sáez Valdenegro,” August 1, 2018, Case No. 12,618-2018.
Santiago Court of Appeals, Protection Action, “González Saldías vs. Carabineros Hospital,” February 28, 2019, Case No. 10,893-2019.
Santiago Court of Appeals, Protection Action, “Ríos Tillerías vs. Dr. Sotero del Río Health Complex,” August 6, 2019, Case No. 862-2019.
Supreme Court, Appeal, “Ríos Tillerías vs. Dr. Sotero del Río Health Complex,” December 13, 2019, Case No. 24,199-2019.
Court of Appeals of Valparaíso, Protection Action, “Viña del Mar Clinical Hospital with Vega Ortiz,” May 27, 2020, Case No. 16,842-2020.
Court of Appeals of Copiapó, Protection Action, “Huaso Monseñor Fernando Ariztía Ruiz Provincial Hospital with Fernández,” July 9, 2021, Case No. 219-2021.
Court of Appeals of Santiago, Protection Action, “Metropolitan North Health Service with Saavedra,” August 2, 2021, Case No. 3,253-2021.
Court of Appeals of Valparaíso, Protection Action, “National Health Service Los Andes Hospital with Villarroel,” January 24, 2022, Case No. 52,505-2021.
Court of Appeals of Rancagua, Protection Action, “Rancagua Regional Hospital with Ramírez,” February 7, 2022, Case No. 35-2022.
Court of Appeals of Santiago, Protection Action, “Dr. Roberto del Río Children’s Hospital with Farías,” December 4, 2023, Case No. 16,120-2023.
Court of Appeals of Arica, Protection Action, “Interclínica San José vs. Cuellar,” March 13, 2026, Case No. 626-2025.
b) Colombia
Constitutional Court of Colombia, Ruling T-823 of 2002, “Carmona vs. Hospital Marco Fidel Suárez de Bello - Antioquia,” October 4, 2002.
Constitutional Court of Colombia, Ruling T-052 of 2010, “Álava vs. Saludcoop EPS,” February 2, 2010.
Constitutional Court of Colombia, Ruling T-476 of 2016, “León vs. Salud Total EPS,” September 10, 2016.
Constitutional Court of Colombia, Ruling T-083 of 2021, “DSCL vs. Colombian Institute of Family Welfare,” April 7, 2021.
c) Europe
European Court of Human Rights, Grand Chamber, Pindo Mulla vs. Spain, case No. 15541/20, ruling of September 17, 2024.